THROW STRIKES THROW BALLS GO FOR STRIKEOUT PITCH TO CONTACT NO COMMAND GO FOR DECISIVE BLOW STEAL ALERT BUNT / SQUEEZE SHIFT
AGGRESSIVE APPROACH HHH PP P HH / Groundball % Up H P H / Walk % Up / Extra base hit % Way Up (*1) HH
PATIENT APPROACH PPP / Hit % down HH / Extra base hit % up (*1) H / Extra base hit % Up P / Groundball % Up / Homerun % down H PP HH / Walk % Up / Extra base hit % Way Up (*1) Neutral
HIT FOR POWER H / Hit % down / Flyball % up P / Flyball % up HH / Extra base hit % up / Flyball % Up PP / Groundball % up/ Homerun % down H / Flyball % Up P HH / Walk % Up / Extra base hit % Way Up (*1) H
HIT FOR CONTACT P / Hit % down H / Extra base hit % up (*1) PP / Flyball % Up HHH H PP H / Walk % Up / Extra base hit % Way Up (*1) HH
NO COMMAND P / Hit % down P P P / Groundball % Up Neutral PPP Neutral / Walk % Up / Extra base hit % Way Up (*1) Neutral
GO FOR DECISIVE BLOW HH H / Extra base hit % up (*1) HH H HHH Neutral HH / Walk % Up / Extra base hit % Way Up (*1) HH
STEAL H Neutral HH Neutral H HH PPP H / Swing and a miss % down
HIT & RUN HH / Swing & miss % down PP / Swing and a miss % small up P / Flyball % Small Up Neutral / Swing and a miss % Down Neutral PP H / Swing and a miss % down H / Swing and a miss % down
SAC BUNT H (*2) H (*2) H (*2) H (*2) H H H P
SQUEEZE Neutral P Neutral Neutral Neutral H Neutral P (*3)
BUTCHER BOY P / Flyball % small up PP / Flyball % small up PP / Flyball % small up P / Flyball % small up H PP / Flyball % small up P / Flyball % small up / Walk % Up / Extra base hit % Way Up HHH / Groundball % Big Up / Strikeout % Big Down
STEAL HOME P P P P P P H (*4) P

Legend:

H - Hitter's advantage / P - Pitcher's advantage
HH - Big Hitter Advantage / PP - Big Pitcher Advantage
HHH - Huge Hitter Advantage / PPP - Huge Pitcher Advantage

*1 - Only when a runner is at first base
*2 - As long as the defense has no bunt alert/shift on
*3 - There will be a 50% chance for a pitchout to get the runner coming home from 3rd base
*4 - If a runner steals 2nd, the catcher will throw to 2nd, giving the 3rd base runner a better chance to steal home